What makes a SOAP document a message

Mark Baker
comments on Steve Maine‘s “Web Services Kernel” post and says:

“A SOAP envelope is not a SOAP message, and pretending otherwise turns a perfectly good document wrapper into a perfectly crappy application protocol.”

Hmmm… I think Mark makes a good point but I also believe that it is all relative. You see, in real life, an envelope is nothing but a folded piece of paper. It has no meaning on its own. However, it’s only when you fill this folded piece of paper with written pages, you put a recipient and a sender address, you attach a stamp on to it, and send/post it, it becomes a letter. Anyone seeing it on the way will say that this is a letter; they won’t say it’s a folded piece of paper.

The same with a SOAP documents. A SOAP document with some WS-Addressing information and some payload becomes a SOAP message. When you see one, you know that it’s a message and not just a document. It’s the transmission of such documents (the messages) that makes it possible for us to build WS applications.

Labels are relative me thinks 🙂

Recent Posts

The boat is in the water: Spring Voyage is open source

Today I'm pushing Spring Voyage out of the harbor. You can track its journey on…

1 week ago

My Coding Agent Needed Its Own GitHub Identity

In my last post, I wrote that "the typing of code was parallelized and delegated.…

2 months ago

Rebuilding My AI Team in Twelve Days — And Why

In February, I wrote about the small team I'd stood up instead of hiring humans:…

2 months ago

How I Built My Own Team of AI Developers

Assembling a dream team without a single hire I've been making great progress on CVOYA's…

4 months ago

Reflecting on 2025: Building CVOYA’s Future with AI Coding Agents

As 2025 is now behind us, I wanted to share a few reflections from my…

5 months ago

DIY smart home accessory – It all started with a question to ChatGPT

Few months ago, we bought a sculpture from a local art fair for our Palm…

6 months ago